23 August 2021
Over time there have been many years or parts of years which have, with or without the benefit of hindsight, been viewed as “key moments”
As we pack our satchels for a new school term, I have been reflecting that the summer of 2021 is also likely to be viewed as a “moment” in the natural, business and political worlds.
In particular, there have been totemic occurrences in:
On Monday 28 June the temperature in Portland Oregon hit 116 degrees Fahrenheit (46.6 Centigrade). The even more staggering statistic, though, was that this was 9 degrees Fahrenheit (5 Centigrade) higher than the previous record high. There were also heatwaves elsewhere. Moscow, for example, had its hottest ever June day on 23 June (34.8 Centigrade).
And then came the extraordinary rains in Germany in July. As we all saw, trucks and houses were picked up and thrown around like toys and many lives were tragically lost. In the Stammheim district of Cologne 154mm of rain fell in one day, obliterating the previous daily record of 95mm.
We already knew that big and worrying things were happening to the climate but the shattering of existing records hammered the point home (if you’ll forgive the jumbled metaphors).
So, it was no surprise to read the conclusions of the IPCC Report on Climate Change issued on 7 August and signed off by 234 scientists from more than 60 countries. The world is likely to reach 1.5C of warming compared to pre-industrial levels within 20 years, even in a best-case scenario of emissions cutting. António Guterres, UN Secretary General, described the report as a “code red for humanity”.
All of this must, of course, focus the minds of world leaders on agreeing a route to net zero emissions at the COP 26 summit in November and supercharge corporate climate transition plans. But there are a plethora of other themes to be kept front of mind. They include:
The last few months have seen continued activity in the UK by traditional activist investors. Elliott are challenging the future role of Dame Emma Walmsley at GlaxoSmithKline, the curiously named Cat Rock Capital is upset about Just Eat Takeaway’s “deeply flawed communication” and Cevian is, with some success, pressing Aviva to increase returns to shareholders.
Whilst Drahi’s recent acquisition of a 12.1 percent stake in BT is not a typical activist play, I have to mention it. The slick purchase of an interest which is just a whisper higher than the size of BT’s other big shareholder (Deutsche Telekom) is an engagingly cheeky move by a smart investor. Surely there is a decent mini-series coming here.
Over this same period, however, two rather different forms of shareholder activism have made striking appearances.
The first is what we might describe as long shareholder push-back on takeover recommendations.
The UK is in the middle of a takeover boom. Buy-out firms have done 13 public-to-private deals worth $31 billion so far this year and strategic buyers are also in the market (Parker Hannifin’s bid for Meggitt is an example). But, within this boom, we are seeing target shareholders take a noticeably more muscular approach than hitherto in being willing to challenge the board’s recommendation to accept a bid.
A few examples are:
The second type of activism to make a splash is climate activism.
The success in late May of Engine No. 1, an activist fund founded in San Francisco only last year, in installing three directors on the Board of ExxonMobil was stunning. With only 0.02% of the company’s stock Engine No 1’s feat was extraordinary and spoke powerfully of the resonance of their message, with the broader investor-base, that the energy experience of their nominees would aid the company’s transition from fossil fuels.
Activists had other successes in May.
At BP, Dutch activist group Follow This received the support of 21% of shareholders for a resolution seeking to press the Board to set more aggressive transition targets, in opposition to the Board’s recommended plan. Whilst the resolution failed, the meaningful support will keep the pressure on the Board. And at Royal Dutch Shell a Dutch court ordered Shell to ensure that its net carbon emissions were 45% lower in 2030 than in 2019. The decision will be appealed but it is another win for climate activism.
The significance of all this is underlined by the climatic extremes experienced in June and July. And the message for Boards is surely that the wheel has turned. Motivated climate and ESG activists, who might until now have been seen as fringe operators, are likely to find more support among traditional investors who are increasingly focussed on demonstrating their own ESG credentials.
Whilst hydrocarbon businesses will naturally attract most attention, businesses in all sectors would be well advised to get on the front foot. One example of that which we are seeing in the UK is the developing trend of PLCs putting climate transition plans to advisory shareholder votes.
The FT reported that thirty four Chinese companies raised a record $12.4 bn in New York in the first half of 2021. That’s a lot. Then, on 6 July, Chinese cyberspace regulators announced an investigation into the ride-hailing app of Didi which had listed on 30 June. Cue a 25% fall in its share price. It has since fallen much further.
6 July will surely be seen as a critical turning point in China’s state interventionism.
Since then it has been made illegal for tutoring companies to make profits, raise capital or list abroad. A sector eviscerated - so much for those who bought shares in, for example, New Oriental Education and Technology Group (down 90 percent from highs at the end of 2020). Then Beijing said on 25 July that it would “notably improve order” in the property management sector resulting in a 17% fall in the Hong Kong share price of industry leader Country Garden Services.
The prelude to these developments was seen in the peremptory cancellation of the flotation of Ant Group late last year, the anti-trust investigation into Alibaba and the apparent humbling of Jack Ma. The implementation of the National Security Law in Hong Kong is an additional chapter in the story.
Much has been written to speculate on what all this means. For example:
But, however one reads these tealeaves, the big takeaway for investors and business counterparties is that unpredictability is the order of the day. Rules can change overnight, governance norms are not normal and recourse for aggrieved investors is doubtful. This will be reflected in investor caution and “China discount”.
Another important point made by John Plender is that if US-China friction in the financial arena runs out of control the consequences could be profound - “The global financial alchemy whereby the relatively poor Chinese help finance rich countries’ pensions is no longer a given.”
I could be wrong here but I do think that a switch has been flipped over recent months, at least in the UK, when it comes to gender diversity in business leadership.
In May Linklaters elected its first female senior partner, Aedamar Comiskey, in its 180-year history and Ashurst elected Karen Davies as its first ever Global Chair. These appointments followed on from the previous elections of Georgia Dawson as Senior Partner at Freshfields and Rebecca Maslen-Stannage as Senior Partner and Chair at Herbert Smith Freehills.
This is a striking change of gear in the world of leading law firms, where Senior and Managing Partners have traditionally been male, and will send a strong message of inclusiveness to clients, team members and potential recruits.
In the corporate world, Rolls Royce announced in June that Anita Frew will succeed Sir Ian Davis as Chair. She will be the first female chair of this totemic engineering company in its 115-year history (one can see the parallels with Linklaters here). Again, there have been other recent appointments of women to senior Chair roles at Schroders, National Grid, Prudential and Electrocomponents. The winds of change are blowing through the senior echelons of UK plc boardrooms
To underline the importance of diversity, moreover, the Financial Conduct Authority is consulting on changes to its Listing Rules which would require listed companies to make an annual comply or explain statement as to whether they have achieved certain targets:
The FCA is aiming to introduce the changes to companies with accounting periods starting on or after January 1 2022.
It would be disrespectful not to mark here the terrible events which have unfolded this month in Afghanistan. A few short weeks after the US withdrawal, the country has fallen to the Taliban and we have seen heart-breaking pictures of desperate citizens clinging to the undercarriage of a US military plane in an effort to escape the country.
It is a tragedy for the people of a blighted country, particularly its women and its young. It will further destabilise a region of the world in desperate need of stability. It can only, moreover, weaken American international prestige at a time when the balance of US/China influence in the world is delicately poised.
One final reflection for this Summer of ’21.
The pandemic has wrought awful pain and loss for many but could we really have thought, last summer, that excellent vaccines would have been discovered and delivered into arms at such speed and in such quantity? Could we have expected economies to recover so quickly (4.8% growth in UK GDP in Q2)? Could we have expected employment to remain so strong? We couldn’t. There is a long way to go, of course, and many bumps in the road no doubt but the fact that so much has been achieved in the face of adversity is a huge endorsement of human ingenuity, resilience and team spirit.
And we have live music back. I leave you with Bryan Adams and Summer of ’69 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HtipPCt317Y - so well known to the audience that they sing the first verse instead of Mr Adams.
12 January 2023
One well-informed Russia observer told me confidently recently that this would be Putin’s last winter in power. I’m not so sure...
12 December 2022
The baby boomers amongst us will remember Ian Dury. His big hit was essentially a list of quirky reasons to be cheerful. It resonates with me now because 2022 has been such a difficult year. So, it behoves us to celebrate the “good bits” of the year.
03 November 2022
“We prefer Global Elite”, he explained with a wry smile, “Magic Circle is a bit too UK centric”. What’s going on?
28 September 2022
She reigned for 70 years and 214 days, 7 years more than Queen Victoria, and has been the very embodiment of constancy.
26 July 2022
Some rhythms just happen (breathing) and some are created, like music and regular behavioural ways of doing or saying things.
21 April 2022
After the largesse of 2021, what are the levers needing to be pulled ahead of 2022
15 March 2022
What we are all seeing unfold as Russia pounds Ukraine is heart breaking, humbling and, for many, simply incomprehensible.
11 January 2022
7 Themes which I believe will be relevant for PLC Directors to keep in mind in 2022
22 November 2021
Inspired by the exciting nip and tuck of a TV story to get our board and pieces out
05 October 2021
The need to balance pragmatism with positivity.
09 June 2021
Are we all guilty of over-reaction to events or just the lack of the will to make things simple?
12 May 2021
What causes us to 'keep up' with those who are moving faster than we are?
19 April 2021
With its 230 pages and 98 consultation questions
22 February 2021
Do you buy the 4-pack of standard Magnum Almond or the 6-pack of Mini-Magnum Almond?